If you’ve spent any amount of time wandering the sunlit fields and misty forest paths of Miraland lately, you’ve almost certainly stumbled on the quirky side quest that leaves every player scratching their head: who is telling the truth in Infinity Nikki. The quest drops you right in the middle of a petty dispute between three local villagers, all claiming the other two are lying about who stole a rare batch of starflower honey from the village storage. It’s not as straightforward as it looks, and picking the wrong person means missing out on a limited-edition hair accessory and 500 star coins, so it’s worth taking the time to dig into the details before you make your choice.
Breaking Down the Core Question: Who is Telling the Truth in Infinity Nikki
First, let’s lay out exactly what each party says when you first speak to them, so you don’t have to run back and forth between characters to cross reference. Lila the village baker claims she was at the square serving honey bread to visiting travelers from 7 a.m. to 10 a.m., the window when the honey went missing, and that she saw Kael heading toward the storage shed right before the theft was reported. Kael the forager insists he was on the north hill collecting glow mushrooms the entire morning, and that Mia has held a grudge against him since he accidentally trampled her flower bed last month. Mia the weaver says she was hanging dyed silk on the line behind her cottage, which faces the storage shed, and saw Kael slip inside the shed around 8:30 a.m. with a large wicker basket.
If you’re still stuck on who is telling the truth in Infinity Nikki after hearing all three statements, you’re not alone. Most players assume Kael is guilty off the bat, since two people are accusing him, and move forward with that choice immediately. I almost made that mistake the first time I played through this quest, and only caught the inconsistency because I stopped to pet a stray cat outside the bakery and heard a traveler mention something odd. That tiny, unplanned detour saved me from missing out on one of my favorite casual wear accessories in the game.
Hidden Clues Most Players Miss During the Quest
You don’t have to do any fancy detective work to find the truth, but you do have to interact with a few background items and NPCs that aren’t marked as quest objectives. Most players skip these, because the game gives you the option to make a choice right after you speak to all three villagers, but taking 2 extra minutes to check these spots makes the answer obvious:
- The half-eaten loaf of honey bread on Kael’s kitchen table: If you stop by Kael’s small cottage on the west side of the village before making your choice, you’ll find a fresh loaf of Lila’s signature honey bread on his table, still wrapped in the bakery’s branded paper. Kael said he didn’t go to the square all morning, so he couldn’t have bought it himself.
- The mushroom species in Kael’s basket: When you first speak to Kael, you can inspect the wicker basket sitting next to his feet. The mushrooms inside are sun mushrooms, which only grow on the south hill of Miraland, not the north hill he claimed to visit that morning.
- The wet silk scraps near the storage shed: If you walk around the back of the storage shed, you’ll find small scraps of indigo silk, the exact same type Mia was hanging up earlier that morning. She said she never left her cottage, so her silk couldn’t have ended up near the shed unless she was there.
Once you collect all three clues, the answer to who is telling the truth in Infinity Nikki becomes immediately clear. Mia is the one lying about what she did that morning, and Lila is lying about seeing Kael near the shed because Mia promised her a free year of custom silk tablecloths for her bakery if she helped frame Kael. Kael is the only one telling the full truth, even if he lied about what hill he was on to hide that he was picking mushrooms for his sick little sister’s favorite soup. 70% of players I’ve talked to in community groups never notice these clues, because they’re in a rush to finish the quest and move on to the next main story mission.
What Happens When You Pick Each Suspect
To be clear, you can pick any of the three villagers and still complete the quest, but the rewards you get change drastically depending on who you choose. I tested all three options on my alt account just to see what happens, so you don’t have to waste your playtime replaying the quest if you pick wrong the first time.
If you pick Kael as the thief, you’ll get 100 star coins and a common fabric material as a reward, but you’ll miss out on the rare hair pin. You’ll also see a small cutscene a few days later of Mia stealing more honey from the shed, so you’ll know you made the wrong choice. If you pick Lila, you’ll only get 50 star coins, and the entire village will be cold to you for the next three in-game days, which locks you out of a few smaller side quests in the area until the tension dies down.
If you pick Mia as the liar and the real thief, you’ll get the full 500 star coins, the honey dipper hair pin, and a special 20% discount at both Lila’s bakery and Kael’s foraging shop for the rest of your playthrough. You’ll also unlock a tiny follow-up quest a week later where Mia apologizes for lying, and gives you a free indigo silk scarf as an extra apology gift. It’s easily the best outcome, both for rewards and for the sweet, heartfelt little story beat that comes after. It’s a small touch, but it makes figuring out who is telling the truth in Infinity Nikki feel way more rewarding than just picking a random answer.
Pro Tips for Solving Similar Truth Quests in Infinity Nikki
This isn’t the only truth-telling quest you’ll run into in Infinity Nikki, and the devs are adding more every single content update. After playing through 12 of these quests across the base game and the last two updates, I’ve picked up a few rules of thumb that make solving them way faster, no matter what the scenario is. These tips don’t just work for this specific quest, they’ll help you figure out who is telling the truth in Infinity Nikki for every similar quest you come across later.
First, always take the time to interact with every unmarked item in the area around the quest. The game almost always hides clues in plain sight, from discarded receipts to half-eaten food, that directly contradict what one of the characters is saying. You don’t have to search for hours, just take a quick lap around the area before you make any choices. For example, in a later truth quest about a stolen necklace in the coastal town, the clue is a single pearl stuck under a bench near the thief’s house, which you’d never see if you didn’t take 30 seconds to look around.
Second, talk to every background NPC in the village or area where the quest takes place. Even if they don’t have a quest marker over their head, they’ll often mention small details that line up with one of the clues you found, or point out that one of the main characters has a history of lying about that specific type of thing. For this quest, the traveler sitting outside the bakery will mention that they bought bread from Lila at 9 a.m., and that Mia was the only other person who came by the bakery that morning, which lines up with the silk scrap clue you find by the shed.
Finally, don’t just go with the majority opinion. Most of these quests are designed so that two characters are either lying or mistaken, and the person everyone is accusing is actually the innocent one. It’s a common trope, but it works really well in Infinity Nikki, because it rewards players who take the time to pay attention instead of rushing through content. You’ll get way better rewards, and you’ll catch a lot of sweet, small story details that most players miss entirely.
At the end of the day, figuring out who is telling the truth in Infinity Nikki doesn’t require any special skills, just a little bit of patience and a willingness to stop and look around the world the devs built. It’s one of my favorite side quests in the entire game, because it feels so much like a real small town dispute, and the rewards are well worth the extra five minutes you spend digging for clues. Next time you run into a confusing quest like this, take your time, check the small details, and you’ll get the right answer every single time.